Holey Cream Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Holey Cream, a delightful gem nestled in the heart of Hell's Kitchen, New York. Specializing in desserts, this spot stands out for its enticing menu featuring both donuts and an extensive array of ice cream flavors.
Each scoop is a treat, boasting creations like Muddy Boots and Midnight Cookies and Cream, each priced at an affordable $8. For those seeking lighter options, the fat-free sorbets, like Mango and Lemon, offer a refreshing alternative at $8 as well. Customers rave about the generous portions and vibrant flavors, making it hard to choose just one!
With a cozy yet unpretentious vibe, Holey Cream is perfect for a quick dessert fix. Whether you're after a refreshing milkshake or a decadent donut, this spot promises a sweet experience that is both enjoyable and memorable.
Ice Cream
HOLeY MOLeY Ice Cream
Vanilla ice cream loaded with M&M's, cookie dough and fudge.
Muddy Boots Ice Cream
Creamy vanilla ice cream loaded with a rich caramel ripple and decadent brownie chunks
S'mores
Brownie a la Mode Ice Cream
Sea Salt Caramel
Outrageous Chocolate Peanut Butter Deluxe Ice Cream
HOLeY Peanut Butter M&M Ice Cream
PB Ice Cream loaded with M&Ms, Choc Chunks and Oatmeal Cookies. Must Try!
Irish Coffee
Made with Jameson!
Outrageous Java Guatemala Ice Cream
Outrageous Deep Belgian Chocolate Chip Ice Cream
Cherry Blossom Ice Cream
Sweetly sublime cherry ice cream bursting with plump, dark Bordeaux cherries
Outrageous Long Island Raspberry Rhapsody Ice Cream
Outrageous Dulce de Leche Ice Cream
Outrageous Caramel Pretzel Ice Cream
Outrageous Strawberry Cheesecake Ice Cream
Creamy Cheesecake Ice Cream with Northwest Strawberries and a Graham Cracker Ripple.
Vanilla Ice Cream
Chocolate Ice Cream
Cookies and Cream Ice Cream
Strawberry Ice Cream
Midnight Cookies and Cream Ice Cream
Green Mint Chip Ice Cream
Pistachio Ice Cream
Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Ice Cream
Rum Raisin Ice Cream
Butter Pecan Ice Cream
Butterscotch Praline Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Crunch Ice Cream
Moose Track Ice Cream
Coffee Oreo Ice Cream
Birthday Cake Ice Cream
Hotel Black Bottom Pie Ice Cream
Matcha Green Tea
Fat Free NO Sugar Added Vanilla w/ Raspberry Ripple
Reduced fat butter pecan flavored ice cream with fresh roasted pecans and swirled with NSA fat free chocolate syrup
Wild Blueberry Ice Cream
Wild Maine blueberry flavored ice cream with a homemade blueberry ripple running throughout
Coconut Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Oreo
Milky Way Ice Cream
Peanut Butter Caramel Cookie Dough Ice Cream
Creamy Vanilla Fat Free Frozen Yogurt
FAT FREE DUTCH CHOCOLATE YOGURT
Chocolate Peanut Butter Frozen Yogurt
Raspberry Chip Low Fat Frozen Yogurt
Mint Chocolate Chip Low Fat Frozen Yogurt
Cookies and Cream Low Fat Frozen Yogurt
Chocolate Fat Free Frozen Yogurt
Peanut Butter Twist Low Fat Frozen Yogurt
Dutch Chocolate Frozen Yogurt (Fat Free)
Frozen Yogurt
Sorbets
Raspberry Sorbet (Fat Free)
Perfectly ripe raspberry puree blended into a delicious sorbet.
Mango Sorbet (Fat Free)
Juicy ripe tropical mango puree blended into a delicious sorbet.
Lemon Sorbet (Fat Free)
Tart lemons blended into a delicious sorbet.
Donut Ice Cream Sandwich
One donut icing, unlimited dry toppings and up to two ice creams.
Famous Donut Ice Cream Sandwich
Flavored Frozen Treats
Medium Frozen Treat
Large Frozen Treat
Pint Frozen Treat
Quart Frozen Treat
Banana Split Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream, sliced banana, chocolate syrup and cake crunch.
Famous Hot Fudge Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream.Four scoops of ice cream, famous hot fudge and cake crunch.
Holy Cream Surprise Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream. Toppings are the chef's surprise.
Peanut Butter Cup Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream, hot fudge, peanut butter sauce and Reese's peanut butter cups.
Make Your Own Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. toppings of your choice. includes whipped cream.
Brownie Explosion Sundae
Choose 2 flavors of ice cream. Four scoops of ice cream, chocolate syrup and brownie chunks.
Sundaes
Beverages
Bottled Soda
Fresh Lemonade
Bottled Water
3 Pint Special
PINT SPECIALS
Hot Fresh Hand-Dipped Donuts
Best Seller Dozen Assortment
One each of the following:Chocolate Lover's Assortment (Smores, Nutella, M&M, Oreo), Sprinkle Assortment (Rainbow, Hot Pink, Blue Bomb, Chocolate Rainbow), Candy Donuts Assortment (M&M, Oreo, Heath Bar, Reeses PB Cup)
Sprinkle Dozen Assortment
4 Rainbow Donuts, 4 Hot Pink Donuts, 4 Blue Bomb Donuts
Candy Donuts Assortment (M&M, Oreo, Heath Bar, Reeses PB Cup)
One each of the following four Donuts:M&M, Oreo, Heath Bar, Reeses PB Cup
Chocolate Lover's Assortment (Smores, Nutella, M&M, Oreo)
One each of the following 4 donuts:Smores, Nutella, M&M, Oreo
Sprinkle Assortment (Rainbow, Hot Pink, Blue Bomb, Chocolate Rainbow)
One each of the following 4 donuts:Rainbow, Hot Pink, Blue Bomb, Chocolate Rainbow
Create Your Own Donut
Cookies and Cream Donut
Vanilla icing, Oreo cookie topping and a dark chocolate drizzle.
M&M Donut
Vanilla icing, mini M&M topping and a dark chocolate drizzle.
Grasshopper Donut
Vanilla Icing with Andes Mint Topping
Nutella Donut
Chocolate icing and Nutella filling.
Rainbow Donut
Vanilla icing and rainbow sprinkles.
Smores Donut
Chocolate icing, graham crack topping and marshmallow drizzle.
Dirty Devil Donut
Vanilla icing and cake crunch topping.
PB Cup Donut
Vanilla icing, Reese's peanut butter cups and a dark chocolate drizzle.
Hot Pink Donut
Vanilla icing and hot pink sprinkles.
Snowball Donut
Vanilla icing and white coconut flakes.
Fruit Loop Donut
Strawberry icing and Fruit Loop topping.
Gummie Bear Delight Donut
Vanilla icing and mini gummy bears.
Heath Bar Donut
Vanilla icing and Heath bar topping.
Blue Bomb Donut
Vanilla icing with fluorescent blue sprinkles.
4 Rainbow Donuts
4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and Rainbow Sprinkles.
4 Chocolate Rainbow Donuts
4 Donuts with Chocolate Icing and Rainbow Sprinkles
4 Hot Pink Donuts
4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and Pink Sprinkles.
4 Blue Bomb Donuts
4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and Blue Sprinkles.
4 Dirty Devil Donuts
4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and Chocolate Crunchies
4 Smowball Donuts
4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and White Coconut Flakes.
4 Cookies and Cream Donuts
4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing, Oreo Cookies, and a Chocolate Drizzle.
4 Fruit Loop Donuts
4 Donuts with Fruit Loops and Strawberry Icing
4 M&M Donuts
4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing, M&Ms, and a Chocolate Drizzle.
4 Heath Bar Donuts
4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing, Heath Bar, and a Chocolate Drizzle.
4 Reeses Peanut Butter Cup Donuts
4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing, Reeses PB Cups, and a Chocolate Drizzle.
4 Smores Donuts
4 Donuts with Chocolate Icing, Graham Cracker topping, and a Marshmallow Drizzle
4 Nutella Donuts
4 Chocolate Iced Donuts filled with Nutella.
4 Grasshopper Donuts
4 Donuts with Vanilla Icing and Andes Mints
4 Gummie Bear Donuts
4 Donuts with vanilla icing and Gummie Bears
3 Fudge Brownies
Award Winning Brownies
Caramel Chew Brownie
M&M Brownie
Reeses Brownie (Peanut Butter Cup)
Oreo Brownie
S'mores Brownie
Fudge Brownie
Delicious Brownies
Cupcakes
Oreo Cookies and Cream Cupcake
Vanilla Sprinkle Cupcake
Chocolate Cupcake
Red Velvet Cupcake
Three Jumbo Cookies
Jumbo Chocolate Chip Cookie
Jumbo Rainbow Sprinkle Cookie
Jumbo Black and White Cookie
Jumbo M&M Cookie
Jumbo Oatmeal Raisin Cookie
Cookies
Milkshakes, Frappes and Ice Cream Soda
Milk Shake
Low-Fat Milk Shake
Malted Shake
Fat-Free Milk Shake
Ice Cream Soda
Holey Frappe
Banana Cream Pie Smoothie
Fat-free vanilla frozen yogurt blended with skim milk, banana and graham crack crumbs.
Berries & Cream Smoothie
Fat-free black raspberry frozen yogurt blended with cranberry juice, strawberries and banana.
Berry Cream Pie Smoothie
Fat free black raspberry frozen yogurt blended with skim milk, strawberries and graham cracker crumbs.
Cran-Pineapple Craze Smoothie
Raspberry sorbet blended with cranberry juice, pineapple chunks and banana.
Beach Breeze Smoothie
Mango sorbet blended with orange juice, pineapple chunks and banana.
Mango Mania Smoothie
Mango sorbet blended with apple juice, mango and banana.
Queen of Tarts Smoothie
Lemon sorbet blended with cranberry juice and raspberries.
Razzo Mango Smoothie
Mango sorbet blended with apple juice, mangos and raspberry.
Strawberry Lemonade Smoothie
Lemon sorbet blended with lemonade and strawberries.
Super Pom Smoothie
Raspberry sorbet blended with blueberry-pomegranate juice, pineapple, raspberries and banana.
Nutella Smoothie
Made with creamy vanilla fat free yogurt, fresh banana and Nutella.